Evidence skills: making a claim checkable before it ships

Source dating and evidence tables are unglamorous skills. They are also the difference between a report that survives review and one that gets walked back.

Nov 20, 2026The avbbc desk
Evidence skills: making a claim checkable before it ships
Source dating and evidence tables are unglamorous skills. They are also the difference between a report that survives review and one that gets walked back.

Most research quality problems are not analysis problems. They are traceability problems: the claim is right, the source is real, and the link between them was lost in the writing. Two skills in the directory exist to keep that link intact.

Evidence Table builds the structure before drafting; Source Dating keeps time-sensitive claims from aging silently.

The short answer

Build an evidence table with sources as rows and questions as columns before writing. Then date every claim that can change. Both are cheap; skipping either is what produces a report that cannot be defended a month later.

The evidence table

The table is a grid: sources down the side, questions across the top, quoted evidence in the cells. Writing from the grid rather than from memory changes the draft, because a sentence with no cell to come from does not get written.

The empty cells are the most useful part. A column of empty cells means the sources do not answer that question, which is a finding rather than a gap to hide. A report that says 'the sources do not answer this' is more credible than one that fills the space with inference.

Source dating

Prices, versions, limits, and organisational facts all expire. Source Dating scans a draft for claims that will age and marks each with what changed and when it was checked.

The rule it enforces is simple: a number without a date is a claim about forever. Most of the time that is not what the writer meant, and the fix is a phrase rather than a rewrite.

Why these are skills, not prompts

Property Evidence Table Source Dating
Consistent output shape Yes Yes
Repeated job Every report Every report
Checkable Cell can be traced Date can be checked
Context cost Pays for itself Small

The fourth row is the argument for a skill: the structure is worth loading because it saves the reader a verification pass. A prompt can do it, but a prompt drifts.

A worked example

A report claims three products fall below a price threshold. The evidence table shows two sources for each price, one dated eight months ago. Source dating marks the old prices, the writer re-checks two pages, and the claim changes from 'is' to 'was, as of this date'. The report is less quotable and more true.

Where the skills stop

They cannot tell you whether a source is right. They can tell you where the claim came from and when it was checked. Whether the source itself is credible is a separate judgement, and usually the one that matters most.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need both? For anything with numbers and third parties, yes. They cover different failures.

What about interviews? Interviews are sources too; date them and quote them. See Interview Note Cluster.

Where do these fit with MCP? Retrieval tools supply the sources; skills structure the evidence. See research skills.

Related reading

All posts